Extensive clinical studies reported in the literature have indicated
that non-operative treatment is the treatment of choice for clavicular
fractures. It has also been suggested by some that open reduction may
contribute to the development of non-union. From 1970 to 1978, twenty-five
of approximately 800 patients with a fracture of the clavicle were treated
by open reduction and internal fixation with a threaded intramedullary wire
or pin or with cerclage suture (one case). The patients' ages ranged from
thirteen to fifty-nine years. All fractures healed without infection or
migration of the pin. Based on this experience and a review of the
English-language literature, we concluded that the indications for open
reduction and internal fixation should be: (1) neurovascular compromise due
to posterior displacement and impingement of the bone fragments on the
brachial plexus, subclavian vessels, and even the common carotid artery;
(2) fracture of the distal third of the clavicle with disruption of the
coracoclavicular ligament; (3) severe angulation or comminution of a
fracture in the middle third of the clavicle; (4) the patient's inability
to tolerate prolonged immobilization (required by closed treatment) because
of Parkinson's disease, a seizure disorder, or other neuromuscular disease;
and (5) symptomatic non-union following treatment by closed methods.