From January 1979 to February 1982, 143 patients (seventy-nine women and
sixty-four men) with 146 uninfected cemented total hip arthroplasties had
revision cemented hip arthroplasty at The Hospital for Special Surgery for
what was considered to be mechanical failure. The average age of the
patients at primary arthroplasty was 56.1 years and at revision, 62.1
years. Loosening of the femoral component before revision correlated with
varus positioning in 50 per cent of the hips, inadequate cement in 34 per
cent, and a relatively young age in 16 per cent. The average age of the
patients (fifteen hips) with a loose femoral component that had been placed
in a neutral or valgus position with good cementing technique was 48.2
years at the time of primary arthroplasty. Loosening of the acetabular
component was attributed to high placement of the cup in 41 per cent,
inadequate bone in 18 per cent, a vertical orientation of the opening of
the cup in 7 per cent, and poor cementing technique in 3 per cent.
Complications associated with revision included perforation of the femoral
cortex in 13 per cent, postoperative deep infection in 3.4 per cent,
postoperative dislocation in 8.2 per cent, trochanteric complications in
6.2 per cent, and sciatic palsy in 0.7 per cent. Of the 139 hips that were
followed for an average of 3.6 years (range, two to five years) after
revision, the results were excellent in 59 per cent, good in 7 per cent,
fair in 16 per cent, and poor in 18 per cent. After revision of the 139
hips, 29 per cent showed progressive radiolucencies; 18 per cent, femoral
subsidence; and 9 per cent, acetabular migration. Definite mechanical
failure after revision was identified in 15.8 per cent of the hips. These
failures were due to loosening in 12.2 per cent of the hips, femoral
fracture in 2.2 per cent, and disabling dislocation in 1.4 per cent. At the
time of follow-up, twelve hips (8.6 per cent) had been revised a second
time: six (4.3 per cent) for loosening of one or both components, three
(2.2 per cent) for femoral fracture, and three (2.2 per cent) for
infection. Mechanical failure and progressive radiolucencies were
associated with poor quality of bone (p less than 0.001) and inadequate
anatomical reconstruction (p less than 0.03).