We studied the cases of 218 patients who had had trauma to the upper
region of the thoracic spine (first to tenth thoracic vertebra) that
resulted in paralysis. Of these, 184 patients had a complete and
thirty-four had an incomplete lesion of the spinal cord. Of the 184
patients who had a complete lesion of the spinal cord, none of the 149
patients who were followed for two to fifteen years recovered any
significant neurological function, regardless of the type of operative or
non-operative treatment. Thirty of the patients with an incomplete lesion
of the spinal cord were followed for two to twenty years. Three others were
lost to follow-up, and one died with ascending necrosis of the spinal cord
and pulmonary failure three months after the laminectomy. Of the remaining
thirty patients, twenty-three had an anterior cord syndrome, four had a
central cord syndrome, and three had a Brown-Sequard syndrome. Five
patients with an incomplete lesion were treated without surgery. Three of
these patients recovered the ability to walk while two recovered some
function but were still not able to walk. Seventeen patients with an
incomplete lesion of the spinal cord were treated by laminectomy. Of these
patients, two also had cord-cooling, two had a posterior fusion, and one
had cord-cooling, spine fusion, and posterior instrumentation with
Harrington rods. Five patients recovered partial ability to walk with
braces, four did not, and eight lost neurological function or became
completely paraplegic after surgery and did not recover. Eight patients
with an incomplete lesion of the spinal cord were treated with anterior
transthoracic decompression and fusion, three of whom had had a previous
laminectomy that had not improved their status. Five patients recovered the
ability to walk without aids, two walked with braces, and one recovered
some motor function but was not able to walk. From this study, we concluded
that laminectomy is contraindicated for incomplete lesions of the upper
region of the thoracic spinal cord and that anterior transthoracic
decompression and fusion offers the best chance of recovery of neurological
function.