The outcome in eleven patients in whom Grade-III and IV
spondylolisthesis was treated non-operatively (Group I) was compared with
that in twenty-one patients in whom the same degrees of spondylolisthesis
were treated by posterior interlaminar fusion (Group II). At an average
eighteen-year follow-up of the eleven patients in Group I, four (36 per
cent) were asymptomatic, six (55 per cent) had mild symptoms, and only one
had significant symptoms. Five (45 per cent) had one or more neurological
findings, but none were incontinent. All of the patients in this group led
an active life, and all had required only minor adjustments in their
life-style. At an average twenty-four-year follow-up of the twenty-one
patients in Group II, twelve (57 per cent) were asymptomatic, eight (38 per
cent) had mild symptoms, and only one had significant symptoms. Nine (50
per cent) of the eighteen patients who had a physical examination had one
or more neurological findings. Roentgenographically demonstrated failure of
fusion did not adversely affect the results, and the patients remained
asymptomatic despite the development of pseudarthrosis in one patient and
bending of the fusion mass in three (14 per cent). In situ arthrodesis
provides acceptable results for the patient who has Grade-III or IV
spondylolisthesis and pain that interferes with life-style and that is
unresponsive to non-operative treatment. In the skeletally immature
patient, in situ fusion is recommended for disturbances of gait secondary
to tight hamstrings and when the spondylolisthesis progresses.