A prospective double-blind study was undertaken to evaluate the
usefulness of magnetic resonance imaging in the accurate interpretation of
pathological intra-articular changes in the knee. Forty-seven patients who
were scheduled to have arthroscopy and three patients who wer to have
arthrotomy volunteered for magnetic resonance imaging preoperatively. The
radiologists had no clinical or roentgenographic information about the
patients before the evaluation of the magnetic resonance images, and the
radiologists' interpretations were unknown to the surgeon before the
arthroscopy or arthrotomy was done. Our important observations were limited
to the findings in the menisci and in the anterior cruciate ligament.
Magnetic resonance imaging had a positive predictive value of 75 per cent,
a negative predictive value of 90 per cent, a sensitivity of 83 per cent,
and a specificity of 84 per cent for pathological findings in the menisci.
For complete tears of the anterior cruciate ligament, the positive
predictive value was 74 per cent; the negative predictive value, 70 per
cent; the sensitivity, 61 per cent; and the specificity, 82 per cent. We
believe that magnetic resonance imaging, when combined with clinical and
roentgenographic examination, provides the most accurate non-invasive
source of information that is currently available for pathological findings
in the menisci and in the anterior cruciate ligament.