Arthroscopic acromioplasty was done for a lesion of the rotator cuff in
165 patients: 100 who had stage-II impingement syndrome (no actual tear of
the rotator cuff) (group 1), forty who had a partial tear (group 2), and
twenty-five who had a full-thickness tear (group 3). The operation
consisted of acromioplasty, resection of the coracoacromial ligament and
subacromial bursa, and removal of osteophytes, when present, near the
inferior aspect of the acromioclavicular joint. In the patients who had a
partial or complete tear, minimum debridement of the rotator cuff also was
performed. In group 1, eighty-six patients (eighty-nine shoulders) were
available for review at a minimum follow-up to two years (average, 31.2
months). The preoperative ratings for pain, activities of daily living,
work, and sports improved markedly in eighty-one patients postoperatively.
The most common findings at operation were proliferative subacromial
bursitis and an acromial protuberance. Two complications were recorded.
Seven patients had a subsequent open operation on the shoulder. In group 2,
the average follow-up was 28.9 months (range, twenty-four to forty-eight
months). Of the forty patients, thirty-three had a major improvement in the
ratings for pain, activities of daily living, work, and sports. One
complication, transient palsy of the lateral femoral cutaneous nerve, was
noted. Two patients who had an unsatisfactory result had a second
operation: one, open acromioplasty and the other, repair of the rotator
cuff. In group 3, the average follow-up was 30.8 months (range, twenty-four
to fifty-five months). There were fourteen satisfactory and eleven
unsatisfactory results. Of the twenty-five patients, seven later had open
repair of the rotator cuff, and six had a satisfactory result from that
procedure. No complications were recorded. It was concluded that
arthroscopic acromioplasty is effective in the treatment of isolated
stage-II impingement and partial tears of the rotator cuff. Arthroscopic
treatment of complete tears produced over-all results that were inferior to
those of traditional open repair. Arthroscopic subacromial decompression
cannot be supported as treatment for complete tears of the rotator
cuff.