We created unstable intertrochanteric fractures with a large
posteromedial defect in eighteen pairs of fresh-frozen femora from
cadavera, and used the femora to evaluate the stability of six combinations
of treatment with sliding compression screws and sideplates. The variables
that were tested were high (150-degree) angle plates compared with low
(130-degree) angle plates, the position of the lag-screw in the femoral
head and neck (in the center of the head as seen on both anteroposterior
and lateral roentgenograms compared with posteroinferiorly), and whether or
not medial cortical contact had been re-established with a limited
osteotomy of the greater trochanter. The femora were loaded to the point of
failure. The mode of failure, maximum load to failure, and bending rigidity
of each method of fixation were measured. Of the six types of treatment,
the use of a 150-degree-angle plate, position of the lag-screw in the
center of the head as seen on both anteroposterior and lateral
roentgenograms, and osteotomy of the greater trochanter resulted in the
highest mean load to failure and the greatest rigidity. Over-all,
re-establishment of medial cortical contact by means of an osteotomy of the
greater trochanter significantly improved the mean load to failure and the
rigidity of the fixation. The higher-angle plate, although more difficult
to insert, increased the mean load to failure but had no effect on
rigidity. The position of the lag-screw (in the center of the head as seen
on both anteroposterior and lateral roentgenograms or posteroinferiorly)
had no bearing on the mean load to failure, but it significantly affected
the mode of failure.