Ninety-six patients who had a total of 108 replacements with an
uncemented porous-coated anatomic knee prosthesis were followed for an
average of sixty-four months (range, thirty-nine to ninety-three months).
At the time of the most recent follow-up, twenty-one implants (19 per cent)
had failed, all due to problems with the tibial component. A patellar
component was not used, and no noteworthy patellar problems were
encountered after the operation. There were no infections about the
prostheses, and no femoral implant was revised. The most common cause of
failure was collapse of the anteromedial part of the tibial plateau, which
occurred in fourteen knees. The prosthesis loosened without collapse of
bone in two knees, and five knees were revised because of gross wear of the
polyethylene. When the time of failure was defined as the point at which
revision of the prosthesis was recommended, the cumulative rate of survival
was 84 per cent (95 per cent confidence interval, +/- 7 per cent) at five
years and 77 +/- 10 per cent at six years. When the time of failure was
defined as the point at which the knee replacement was actually done, the
five-year rate of survival was the same. No significant differences were
demonstrated between groups that were stratified by age, sex, weight, or
primary diagnosis. We therefore do not recommend the use of an uncemented
porous-coated anatomic knee replacement of the design that was evaluated in
this study.