JBJS | Solitary Bone Cyst with Epiphyseal Involvement: Confirmation with Magnetic Resonance Imaging. A Case Report and Review of the Literature*

The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, Volume 78, Issue 6

Articles | June 01, 1996

Solitary Bone Cyst with Epiphyseal Involvement: Confirmation with Magnetic Resonance Imaging. A Case Report and Review of the Literature*

ANIL K. GUPTA, M.B., B.S., M.S.(ORTH.)†; ALVIN H. CRAWFORD, M.D.‡, CINCINNATI, OHIO

View Disclosures and Other Information

Investigation performed at Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati

The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery. 1996; 78:911-5

5 Recommendations (Recommend) | 3 Comments | Saved by 3 Users Save Case

Article

Figures

References

text A A A

Introduction

Introduction | Case Report | Discussion | References

Documented epiphyseal extension of a solitary unicameral bone cyst in the presence of an open physis is extremely rare^3,15. Epiphyseal extension by such cysts has been noted on plain radiographs³, on computed tomography¹⁵, and intraoperatively¹⁰. We report an unusual case of a skeletally immature child in whom magnetic resonance imaging clearly demonstrated extension of a solitary bone cyst into the proximal humeral epiphysis. The portions of the cyst in the epiphysis and metaphysis communicated through a defect in the physis that was probably due to erosion by the cyst. Progressive limb-shortening developed. The purpose of the current report is to describe the natural history and pathogenesis of physeal involvement by a unicameral bone cyst.

*No benefits in any form have been received or will be received from a commercial party related directly or indirectly to the subject of this article. No funds were received in support of this study.

†E-199, East of Kailash, New Delhi 110068, India.

‡Division of Orthopaedic Surgery, Children's Hospital Medical Center, 3333 Burnet Avenue, Cincinnati, Ohio 45229-3039.

*No benefits in any form have been received or will be received from a commercial party related directly or indirectly to the subject of this article. No funds were received in support of this study.

†E-199, East of Kailash, New Delhi 110068, India.

‡Division of Orthopaedic Surgery, Children's Hospital Medical Center, 3333 Burnet Avenue, Cincinnati, Ohio 45229-3039.

View Large | Download Slide(.ppt)
Add to My JBJS

Figs. 1-A through 1-F: Roentgenograms and magnetic resonance images of a boy who had a unicameral bone cyst. Fig. 1-A: Roentgenogram, made when the patient was nine years old, showing a pathological fracture through a typical unicameral bone cyst in the proximal part of the humerus. The cyst abuts the physis and extends one to five centimeters from it. There is a small area where the cyst wall forms an interface with the physis. The growth plate otherwise appears intact, and the fracture does not extend to the physis. The sclerosed area in the physis (arrow) could have been the initial site of encroachment; it indicates reactive bone formation before the later fracture through the markedly thinned cortex.

View Large | Download Slide(.ppt)
Add to My JBJS

Roentgenogram, made six weeks later, showing healing with callus formation. There is minimum reactive bone at the physeal line.

View Large | Download Slide(.ppt)
Add to My JBJS

Plain roentgenogram, made five years later, revealing expansion of the cyst into the epiphysis. The physeal line appears to be open. An apparent osseous interface between the cyst wall and the physis is seen throughout the metaphyseal side. The pathological fracture does not appear to involve the physis.

View Large | Download Slide(.ppt)
Add to My JBJS

Spin-density (Fig. 1-D) and T2-weighted (Fig. 1-E) magnetic resonance images of sagittal oblique sections through the proximal part of the humerus. (The repetition time is 2500 milliseconds for both and the echo time, nineteen and ninety-five milliseconds, respectively.) There is high signal intensity in the interlesional matrix in the cyst on the spin-density image, suggesting proteinaceous fluid. The cystic components extend proximally through a defect in the physeal plate into the epiphysis. A healing fracture with mild angulation is seen through the thinned cortex in the distal part of the lesion (Fig. 1-E). The lesion was thought not to be fibrous because of the high signal intensity on the spin-density image and the absence of an adjacent soft-tissue mass on the T2-weighted image, suggesting the diagnosis of a benign lesion such as a solitary or an aneurysmal bone cyst.

View Large | Download Slide(.ppt)
Add to My JBJS

Roentgenogram made one year after the second fracture and treatment of the cyst with intracystic injections of steroids. There is almost complete healing of the cyst and almost total closure of the growth plate.

Case Report

Introduction | Case Report | Discussion | References

A fourteen-year-old boy was seen in the emergency room of the Children's Hospital Medical Center in Cincinnati with a history of a twisting injury of the right arm. He had been managed for a pathological fracture of the humerus on the same side when he was nine years old. Roentgenograms made at that time had revealed a fracture through a unicameral bone cyst (Figs. 1-A and 1-B). He had had no specific problems since that time except that the right arm was noticeably shorter than the left.

The findings on the general physical examination when the patient was fourteen were unremarkable. The findings on the local examination of the right arm were clinically consistent with a fracture of the proximal part of the humerus. The results of the neurovascular examination of the limb were normal. Roentgenograms of the humerus showed the fracture to be through a loculated radiolucent lesion with a thinned cortex in the proximal metaphyseal and diaphyseal region. Proximally, the lesion abutted the physis and had extended into the epiphysis. The growth plate appeared to be open. The fracture did not involve the physis (Fig. 1-C). The fracture was treated with an arm sling. Magnetic resonance imaging was done to evaluate the character and extent of the lesion further.

Spin-density and T2-weighted magnetic resonance images showed a large lesion in the proximal part of the humerus; the maximum proximal-distal diameter measured ten centimeters (Figs. 1-D and 1-E). The lesion began in the mid-portion of the diaphysis and extended proximally through the physeal plate into the adjacent epiphysis. The physeal plate was seen clearly except in the area of the defect. There was no subchondral collapse around the cystic area, and the adjacent soft tissues were apparently normal on the T2-weighted images (Fig. 1-E). The lesion was characterized by septa in a high-signal-intensity matrix. There was extensive thinning of the cortex in the mid-portion, and a cortical fracture was seen in the distal third of the lesion. The signal intensity of the intralesional matrix on the spin-density images indicated proteinaceous fluid (Fig. 1-D).

The patient was managed with aspiration, irrigation with saline solution, and injection of methylprednisolone three times at six-week intervals, according to the standard protocol for the treatment of unicameral bone cysts at our center⁸. Serosanguineous fluid was aspirated each time, and histological examination of the clotted aspirate did not reveal any tumor cells. Progressive healing was noted after each injection.

One year after the most recent injection, the patient had a full, free range of motion of the shoulder and elbow. The right arm had shortening of 4.5 centimeters, compared with 3.8 centimeters at the time of the fracture. Roentgenograms showed a well healed cyst. The growth plate appeared to be almost closed (Fig. 1-F).

Discussion

Introduction | Case Report | Discussion | References

Fifty per cent of solitary bone cysts occur in the proximal metaphyseal region of the humerus^12,23. Cysts in close proximity to the physis have been classified as active and those away from the physis, as latent¹². The apparent migration of the cyst toward the diaphysis is a result of the cyst remaining in the same location as the bone lengthens and the distance between the wall of the cyst and the physeal line increases. Occasionally, persistent juxtaphyseal cysts may extend to involve the epiphyseal region after skeletal maturity^2,12. Epiphyseal involvement in the presence of an open physis is unusual^3,15.

The etiology of epiphyseal involvement by unicameral bone cysts is not clear. In a skeletally immature patient, the growth plate appears to act as a barrier to proximal expansion. However, theoretically there is a risk that a cyst abutting the physis will cause local erosion of the physeal plate and lead to limb-length discrepancy by means of growth retardation^3,6 or stimulation⁵. Most authors have attributed physeal involvement and subsequent growth arrest to traumatic damage^5,14,19. Recent reports have suggested erosion by the cyst as a possible cause of physeal damage and growth arrest^3,25. Malawer and Markle reported on a patient who had involvement of the proximal femoral epiphysis and suggested a vascular etiology because of increased measurements of pulsatile pressure. Those authors also analyzed seven previously reported cases of epiphyseal involvement^{1,2,7,10,12,19,23}. Of four lesions found in children with open physes, two were in the proximal part of the tibia and two were in the proximal part of the femur^7,10,15,23. Two lesions in the proximal part of the humerus and one in the distal part of the femur were detected after closure of the physes^1,19. Shortening of the limb was observed in only one patient and was attributed to previous trauma¹⁹. A vascular etiology was also considered by Clark, who thought that hyperemia after an injury could be responsible for erosion and damage to the physis. Capanna et al. reviewed the roentgenograms of 607 patients who had a unicameral bone cyst and identified twelve who had demonstrable epiphyseal or apophyseal involvement through an open physis. Four of the involved limbs had shortening of more than 2.5 centimeters. According to those authors, the growth-plate cartilage has only a partial inhibitory effect on extension of the tumor or pseudotumor, and growth disturbance ensues after the cyst has extended into the epiphysis³.

A medial epiphyseal slip after a fracture of the proximal part of the humerus can cause further physeal damage and can lead to varus angulation. Recent electron microscopic studies of the growth plate in the area of the cyst also suggested destructive changes involving the hyaline cartilage and proliferative zones of the growth plate²⁵. Chondrocytes exhibited morphological signs of impaired function, such as an increase in glycogen granules and lipid droplets and a reduction in organelles²⁵. Impaired synthesis of the lipoproteins, disappearance of organelles, and fragmentation of cytoplasm were observed, suggesting a severe lesion of the cells and a major role of hydrolytic enzymes in the pathogenesis²⁵. The role of lysosomal enzymes in the formation and persistence of a cyst is also well documented⁹. Increased concentrations of acid phosphatase¹⁶ and high levels of prostaglandins²² in the cyst fluid, consistent with osseous destruction in the cyst wall, have been reported.

Jaffe¹¹ and Neer et al. demonstrated histologically a spongy osseous interface between the cyst wall and the physis in a study of cysts abutting the physis. We believe that this minimum osseous interface is due to the constant osteogenesis at the physeal level, which probably surpasses the biodegradation within an active cyst and thus protects the physeal cartilage from direct exposure to the cyst fluid and its contents. When an active cyst is in an extreme stage of biological degradation, it expands because of the increased hydrostatic pressure^4,6 and the lysosomal⁹ and other enzyme activity^16,25 within it. This causes resorptive erosion and absorption of the interface between the cyst wall and the physis, along with cortical thinning. The attenuated cortex is probably more vulnerable to injury, and a pathological fracture occurs through the thinned cortex before extensive erosion of the growth plate can take place. Decompression of the cyst due to the fracture changes the dynamics of the cyst temporarily in favor of osteogenesis^5,12, but as soon as the fracture has healed the dynamics recur. Cohen observed that increased collateral drainage or removal of the vascular blockage leads to healing of the cyst. This finding is supported by the fact that wider cortical decompression¹⁴ or continued drainage of the cyst⁴ results in good healing.

In the absence of any osseous interface between the cyst wall and the physis, persistent exposure to the contents of the cyst as it expands could cause direct local erosion of the growth plate. The result may be, first, gradual distal erosion of the physis leading to growth inhibition. Complete growth arrest does not occur because the germinal and proliferative zones of the physis are not involved. This corresponds to the physeal involvement reported by Cohen and by Clark. Next, continued erosion of the cartilage may cause a perforation in the growth plate at its weakest point. The growth plate is relieved of the pressure as the metaphyseal portion of the cyst is decompressed and as the cyst expands into the epiphysis. This phenomenon was reported previously, in patients in whom no growth arrest was observed during a three-year follow-up period¹⁰. Such a defect may not inhibit growth until the peripheral portion of the growth plate has also been destroyed. Finally, as the cyst expands on both sides of the physis, growth may be inhibited because of the partial destruction of the physis^3,25. Vascular compromise of the epiphysis has also been suggested as an etiological factor¹¹. Since the growth potential of the physis depends mainly on the vascular supply on the epiphyseal side²⁴, it is possible that the extensive expansion of the cyst may cause vascular disruption and affect the physis and subsequent growth. The combination of these factors was probably responsible for the damage to the physis in our patient.

On the basis of our observations, we believe that growth arrest is related to the damage to the physis caused by the cyst and that it (rather than the previously postulated possibility of extrinsic traumatic damage to the physis^6,17,19) may account for the shortening associated with these lesions. Lesions that abut the physis in young children therefore should be evaluated carefully. Plain roentgenograms alone may not reveal the exact state of the lesion^3,6. Because of its multiplanar imaging and better contrast sensitivity, magnetic resonance imaging is useful for evaluating these benign lesions and for differentiating them from malignant lesions such as purely lytic osteosarcoma²¹. The high signal intensity of the intralesional matrix on the spin-density images of our patient suggested that the lesion probably was not fibrous, and the absence of a soft-tissue mass on the T2-weighted images suggested the diagnosis of a benign lesion with fluid, such as a unicameral or an aneurysmal bone cyst. Critical evaluation of epiphyseal lesions is also essential because a large cyst can cause subchondral collapse, joint incongruity⁷, and avascular necrosis¹³.

Because of the potential for physeal erosion by an active cyst in a young patient, magnetic resonance imaging may be justified. If there is encroachment into the physis, early decompression and definitive treatment should be considered to prevent additional destruction. Recent reports have supported the intracystic injection of steroids for the treatment of unicameral bone cysts without any noticeable effect on the physis^9,15,20,22. Since growth retardation had already begun in our patient long before the injections of steroids, it seems unlikely that the steroids had any important additional effect on the final limb-length discrepancy.

NOTE: The authors thank Dr. George Bisset, M.D., staff radiologist, Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, for his valuable suggestions during the preparation of this manuscript. They also thank the World Health Organization, as the work was done during the tenure of one of us (A. K. G.) on a World Health Organization fellowship.

References

Introduction | Case Report | Discussion | References

Bernhang, A. M., and |and |Dua, N. K.: Solitary bone cyst with epiphyseal involvement. Orthop. Rev.,8: 81-83, 1979.881 1979

Boseker, E. H.; Bickel, W. H.; and |and |Dahlin, D. C.: A clinicopathologic study of simple unicameral bone cysts. Surg., Gynec. and Obstet.,127: 550-560, 1968.127550 1968

Capanna, R.; Van Horn, J.; Ruggieri, P.; and |and |Biagini, R.: Epiphyseal involvement in unicameral bone cysts. Skel. Radiol.,15: 428-432, 1986.15428 1986 [CrossRef]

Chigira, M.; Maehara, S.; Arita, S.; and |and |Udagawa, E.: The aetiology and treatment of simple bone cysts. J. Bone and Joint Surg.,65-B(5): 633-637, 1983.65-B(5)633 1983

Clark, L.: The influence of trauma on unicameral bone cysts. Clin. Orthop.,22: 209-214, 1962.22209 1962 [PubMed]

Cohen, J.: Unicameral bone cysts. A current synthesis of reported cases. Orthop. Clin. North America,8: 715-736, 1977.8715 1977

Czitrom, A. A., and |and |Pritzker, K. P. H.: Simple bone cyst causing collapse of the articular surface of the femoral head and incongruity of the hip joint. A case report. J. Bone and Joint Surg.,62-A: 842-845, July 1980.62-A842 1980

Ferree, B. A., and |and |Crawford, A. H.: Unicameral bone cyst. Orthop. Consult.,11: 1-8, 1990.111 1990

Gerasimov, A. M.; Toporova, S. M.; Furtseva, L. N.; Berezhnoy, A. P.; Vilensky, E. V.; and |and |Alekseeva, R. I.: The role of lysosomes in the pathogenesis of unicameral bone cysts. Clin. Orthop.,266: 53-63, 1991.26653 1991 [PubMed]

Hutter, C. G.: Unicameral bone cyst. Report of an unusual case. J. Bone and Joint Surg.,32-A: 430-432, April 1950.32-A430 1950

Jaffe, H. L.: Tumors and Tumorous Conditions of the Bones and Joints, p. 63. Philadelphia, Lea and Febiger, 1958.

Jaffe, H. L., and |and |Lichtenstein, L.: Solitary unicameral bone cyst with emphasis on the roentgen picture, the pathological appearance and the pathogenesis. Arch. Surg.,44: 1004-1025, 1942.441004 1942

Khermosh, O., and |and |Weissman, S. L.: Coxa vara, avascular necrosis, and osteochondritis dissecans complicating solitary bone cysts of the proximal femur. Clin. Orthop.,126: 143-146, 1977.126143 1977 [PubMed]

McKay, D. W., and |and |Nason, S. S.: Treatment of unicameral bone cysts by subtotal resection without grafts. J. Bone and Joint Surg.,59-A: 515-519, June 1977.59-A515 1977

Malawer, M. M., and |and |Markle, B.: Unicameral bone cyst with epiphyseal involvement: clinico-anatomic analysis. J. Pediat. Orthop.,2: 71-79, 1982.271 1982 [CrossRef]

Markovic, B.; Cvijetic, A.; and |and |Karakasevic, J.: Acid and alkaline phosphatase activity in bone-cyst fluid. J. Bone and Joint Surg.,70-B(1): 27-28, 1988.70-B(1)27 1988

Moed, B. R., and |and |LaMont, R. L.: Unicameral bone cyst complicated by growth retardation. Report of three cases. J. Bone and Joint Surg.,64-A: 1379-1381, Dec. 1982.64-A1379 1982

Neer, C. S., II; Francis, K. C.; Johnston, A. D.; and |and |Kiernan, H. A., Jr.: Current concepts on the treatment of solitary unicameral bone cyst. Clin. Orthop.,97: 40-51, 1973.9740 1973 [PubMed][CrossRef]

Nelson, J. P., and |and |Foster, R. J.: Solitary bone cyst with epiphyseal involvement. A case report. Clin. Orthop.,118: 147-150, 1976.118147 1976 [PubMed]

Scaglietti, O.; Marchetti, P. G.; and |and |Bartolozzi, P.: The effects of methylprednisolone acetate in the treatment of bone cysts. Results of three years follow-up. J. Bone and Joint Surg.,61-B(2): 200-204, 1979.61-B(2)200 1979

Schlesinger, A. E., and |and |Hernandez, R. J.: Diseases of the musculoskeletal system in children: imaging with CT, sonography, and MR. AJR: Am. J. Roentgenol.,158: 729-741, 1992.158729 1992 [PubMed]

Shindell, R.; Connolly, J. F.; and |and |Lippiello, L.: Case report. Prostaglandin levels in a unicameral bone cyst treated by corticosteroid injection. J. Pediat. Orthop.,7: 210-212, 1987.7210 1987 [CrossRef]

Tachdjian, M. O.: Pediatric Orthopedics, p. 516. Philadelphia, W. B. Saunders, 1972.

Trueta, J., and |and |Amato, V. P.: The vascular contribution to osteogenesis III. Changes in the growth cartilage caused by experimentally induced ischaemia. J. Bone and Joint Surg.,42-B(3): 571-587, 1960.42-B(3)571 1960

Vasilev, V.; Andreeff, I.; Sokolov, T.; and |and |Vidinov, N.: Clinical-morphological and electron-microscopic studies of the growth plate in solitary bone cysts. Arch. Orthop. and Trauma Surg.,106: 232-237, 1987.106232 1987 [CrossRef]

Topics