Background: The purpose of this study was to
determine the accuracy of computed tomography and fluoroscopy in
assessing joint penetration by periacetabular screws.
Methods: A 3.5-mm acetabular periarticular
screw was inserted in each of thirty-nine cadaveric hemipelves.
Twenty screws were intentionally directed to violate the articular
surface, whereas nineteen screws were positioned to avoid the articular
surface. Using two fluoroscopic views (tangential and axial) in
a manner simulating the clinical setting, an examiner blinded to
the actual screw location determined whether each screw was violating
the articular surface. In addition, each hemipelvis was examined
with computed tomography with use of two different techniques: (1)
a 1-mm slice thickness at 1-mm intervals, and
(2) a 4-mm slice thickness at 3-mm intervals. Each scan was
evaluated by another examiner who was blinded to the actual screw
location. Sensitivity, specificity, and percent correct interpretations
were then calculated for each method.
Results: The sensitivity, specificity, and percent
correct interpretations were 95%, 84%, and 90%,
respectively, for axial fluoroscopy; 85%, 89%,
and 87% for tangential fluoroscopy; 100%, 84%, and
92% for the computed tomography scans with a 1-mm slice
thickness at 1-mm intervals; and 100%, 58%, and
79% for the computed tomography scans with a 4-mm slice
thickness at 3-mm intervals. Tangential fluoroscopy was found to be
more specific than the computed tomography scans with a 4-mm slice
thickness at 3-mm intervals (p = 0.02). No other significant
differences were found.
Conclusions: Fluoroscopy and computed tomography
are equally accurate for determining intra-articular screw penetration.
Computed tomography scans with thick slices (4 mm at 3-mm intervals) have
a low specificity. Their use postoperatively may lead to a false-positive
interpretation of the scan and unnecessary exploration of a hip
for screw penetration.
Clinical Relevance: Both intraoperative fluoroscopy
and postoperative computed tomography are accurate methods for evaluating
intra-articular screw penetration. If postoperative computed
tomography is used, 1-mm slices at 1-mm intervals should
be chosen. Fluoroscopy has the advantage of enabling intraoperative
diagnosis.