Background: There is no ideal treatment for end-stage degenerative
wrist disorders and subsequent carpal collapse. The purpose of this study was
to investigate whether autologous cartilage constructs tissue-engineered from
bone-marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells can be effective for carpal bone
reconstruction.
Methods: Total lunate excision was performed in twenty-seven adult
New Zealand White rabbits. Mesenchymal stem cells were isolated from marrow
and then were culture-expanded. Group-1 rabbits underwent excision only.
Group-2 animals underwent excision followed by implantation of a scaffold
consisting of gelatin and hyaluronan. Group-3 animals underwent excision
followed by implantation of a mesenchymal stem cell-seeded scaffold that had
been preincubated in chondrogenic medium. The group-1 animals were killed at
six weeks, whereas the group-2 and group-3 animals were killed at six or
twelve weeks. Tissues were harvested for radiographic and histologic
analysis.
Results: Significant carpal collapse (a 5.4% ± 2.8% reduction
in the carpometacarpal index, p < 0.05) was observed in the group-1 animals
by six weeks. In contrast, the carpal height was maintained in the group-2 and
3 animals. There was no radiographic evidence of ossification in the group-1
or 2 animals, whereas there was radiographic evidence of ossification in all
six group-3 rabbits killed at the twelve-week time-point. Histologic sections
from the group-3 animals showed filling of the lunate space with islands of
cartilage with interspersed bone ossicles at six weeks. At twelve weeks, there
was abundant bone formation as well as evidence of neovascularization. Osseous
tissue was present in the central portions of the constructs while the
periphery was lined with cartilage. In groups 1 and 2, the lunate space was
filled with poorly organized fibrous tissue.
Conclusions: Cartilaginous implants preformed from autologous
mesenchymal stem cells seeded onto biodegradable scaffold can prevent carpal
collapse. The newly formed osteochondral tissue appears to function as an
adequate biologic lunate spacer for at least twelve weeks in this animal
model.
Clinical Relevance: To our knowledge, this is the first report of
whole-bone reconstruction performed with the use of mesenchymal stem cells.
Biologic constructs that are tissue-engineered from mesenchymal stem cells may
be a new alternative for carpal arthroplasty in patients with clinical
conditions such as osteonecrosis.